OFC ALL-STARS
These awards were previously called the Schenley Awards
2019 - Spencer Foster - Receiver | 2008 - Jamike Njoku - Linebacker | 1989 - Mike Pierotti - Offensive Line | |
| 2018 - Spencer Foster - Receiver | 2008 - Miguel Wason - Defensive Back | 1989 - Moe Lawrence - Receiver | |
| 2018 - Tyler Lovell - Offensive Line | 2008 - Steve Mati - Receiver | 1988 - Martin Farrell - Defensive Back | |
| 2018 - Brendan Hepburn - Defensive Line | 2007 - Jason Nurse - Defensive Lineman | 1988 - Dave Sperandeo - Defensive Line | |
| 2018 - Austin Rowe - Offensive Line | 2007 - Jamike Njoku - Linebacker | 1988 - Rob Annen - Defensive Line | |
| 2018 - Oscar Reddecop - Linebacker | 2007 - Jason Hakkers - Offensive Line | 1988 - Mike Pierotti - Offensive Line | |
| 2017 - Oscar Reddecop - Linebacker | 2006 - Mo Chams - Defensive Back | 1988 - Myke Weis - Receiver | |
| 2017 - George Panagiotopolous - Offensive Line | 2006 - Ashley Squire-Smith - Defensive Line | 1988 - Colin Rous - Running Back | |
| 2017 - Austin Rowe - Offensive Line | 2006 - Chris Andryc - Offensive Lineman | 1987 - Jim Lake - Offensive Line | |
| 2016 - Joel Clubine - Running Back | 2005 - Jon Shreve - Running Back | 1987 - Myke Weis - Receiver | |
| 2016 - Dwaine Stewart - Running Back | 2004 - Curtis Cammaert - Receiver | 1987 - Scott Miller - Quarterback | |
| 2016 - Albert Valentine - Offensive Line | 2003 - Len Gurr - Offensive Line | 1986 - Tony Ristine - Defensive Back | |
| 2016 - Garrett Heming - Defensive Line | 2003 - Dave Stephenson - Defensive Line | 1986 - Jim Lake - Offensive Line | |
| 2016 - Isaiah Nganga - Defensive Back | 2003 - Mike Jones - Defensive Back | 1986 - Brad Halls - Receiver | |
| 2015 - Isaiah Nganga - Defensive Back | 2003 - Rob Umbelina - Punter | 1985 - Lawrence Green - Linebacker | |
| 2015 - Waseem Ghozayel - Linebacker | 2002 - Mike Darling - Offensive Line | 1985 - Jim Reddon - Receiver | |
| 2015 - Matt Wolfe - Place Kicker | 2002 - Mike Jones - Receiver | 1983 - Rod Arquette - Linebacker | |
| 2015 - Matt Long - Defensive Lineman | 2002 - Jeff McKinlay - Defensive Line | 1983 - Peter Bakker - Defensive Line | |
| 2015 - Shaquille Johnson - Receiver | 2002 - Mhoudy Halbouni - Defensive Back | 1983 - John Frizzell - Defensive Back | |
| 2015 - Tylere McKee - Offensive Line | 2002 - Chris Mai - Defensive Back | 1982 - Steve Williams - Linebacker | |
| 2014 - Josh Beach - Quarterback | 2001 - Rob Umbelina - Quarterback | 1982 - Arnold Row - Defensive Line | |
| 2023 - LJ Dyer - Running Back | 2014 - Emmanuel Appiah-Kubi - Linebacker | 2001 - Jason Allison - Running Back | 1982 - Tim Boyd - Quarterback |
| 2023 - Jagger Horst - Receiver | 2014 - Garrett Heming - Defensive Line | 2001 - Slawek Kaczmarek - Offensive Line | 1982 - Ron Almeida - Receiver |
| 2023 - Kevin Ricard - Offensive Line | 2014 - Christian Ridley - Receiver | 2001 - Jeff McKinlay - Defensive Line | 1982 - Eric Crofts - Offensive Line |
| 2023 - Jared Balazs - Offensive Line | 2013 - Josh Beach - Quarterback | 2001 - Paul Testa - Linebacker | 1981 - Ron Almeida - Receiver |
| 2023 - Nkosi Stewart - Defensive Line | 2013 - Aaron Stora-Nelson - Receiver | 2001 - Mhoudy Halbouni - Defensive Back | 1981 - Tom Borton - Punter |
| 2023 - Drew Lawrence - Defensive Back | 2013 - Rico Palcich - Offensive Line | 1998 - Ben Carswell - Punter | 1981 - Bill Howard - Offensive Line |
| 2022 - Dylan Clarke - Defensive Line | 2013 - Josh Franks - Defensive Line | 1998 - Ty Stacyszan - Defensive Back | 1981 - John Talbot - Defensive Line |
| 2022 - LJ Dyer - Running Back | 2013 - Jess Tonn - Defensive Back | 1998 - Mike Davis - Linebacker | 1980 - Ron Almeida - Receiver |
| 2022 - AJ Williamson - Punter | 2013 - Derek Coleman - Defensive Back | 1997 - Curtis Walls - Defensive Back | 1980 - Jason Chorostecki - Running Back |
| 2022 - Jordan Wright - Defensive Back | 2012 - Zack Medeiros - Punter | 1997 - Ben Carswell - Punter | 1979 - Dave Parsons - Offensive Line |
| 2022 - Taz Bell - Running Back | 2012 - Zack Medeiros - Place Kicker | 1996 - Troy Cooper - Running Back | 1979 - Tom Cudney - Receiver |
| 2022 - Willie Mboko - Defensive Back | 2012 - Nathan Caranci - Offensive Line | 1996 - Ben Carswell - Punter | 1978 - Tom Cudney - Receiver |
| 2022 - AJ Williamson - Kicker | 2012 - Josh Woodman - Receiver | 1996 - Mark Geris - Defensive Line | 1978 - Brian Weaver - Linebacker |
| 2021 - Taz Bell - Running Back | 2012 - Kyle Woldenberg-Puyda - Running Back | 1996 - Scott Hamilton - Linebacker | 1978 - Rick Sullivan - Defensive Back |
| 2021 - Mitchel Spence - Receiver | 2012 - Garrett Heming - Defensive Line | 1992 - Jason Appleyard - Kicker | 1977 - Tom Cudney - Receiver |
| 2021 - David Legg - Offensive Line | 2012 - Ian Barrie - Defensive Back | 1991 - Jeff Beraznik - Receiver | 1976 - Pete Enwright - Running Back |
| 2021 - Brayden Bell - Offensive Line | 2011 - Rob Varallo - Defensive Line | 1991 - Geo Langlois - Linebacker | 1976 - Bill Aziz - Offensive Line |
| 2021 - Jordan Fletcher - Defensive Line | 2010 - Chris Van MeppelenScheppink - Defensive Back | 1991 - Greg Aitkin - Defensive Back | 1976 - Gerry Keogh - Linebacker |
| 2021 - Tyler Thompson - Linebacker | 2010 - Tyler Putzer - Offensive Line | 1990 Tony Daugherty - Running Back | 1976 - Dave Rigg - Defensive Back |
| 2021 - Devon Smith - Defensive Back | 2010 - Carmine Gentile - Place Kicker | 1990 - Jeff Holland - Offensive Line | 1976 - John Disbrowe - Defensive Back |
| 2021 - Codey McRoberts - Linebacker | 2009 - Craig Barnett - Offensive Line | 1990 - Mike Pierotti - Offensive Line | 1975 - Daryl Stephenson - Running Back |
| 2019 - Tanner Gaskill-Cadwallader - Defensive Back | 2009 - Aaron Geisler - Running Back | 1990 - Mike Crocker - Receiver | 1975 - John Disbrowe - Defensive Back |
| 2019 - Soren Hallschmid - Defensive Line | 2009 - James Morrissey - Receiver | 1990 - Frank Circelli - Defensive Back | 1975 - Dave Rigg - Defensive Back |
| 2019 - George Panagiotopolous - Offensive Line | 2009 - Miguel Wason - Defensive Back | 1990 Tony Daugherty - Running Back | 1975 - Gerry Keogh - Linebacker |
| 2019 - Matt Bettencourt - Offensive Line | 2009 - Zack Medeiros - Punter | 1990 - Glenn Smith - Defensive Back | 1975 - Bob Babcock - Defensive Line |