Legends 57+ Tier I
| Year | Champion | Province |
| 2025a | ||
| 2024 | Oakville Golden A's | Ontario |
| 2023 | Port Alberni Cubs | British Columbia |
| 2022 | Petit-de-Grat Red Caps | Nova Scotia |
| 2021b | ||
| 2020b | ||
| 2019 | Happy Islanders | British Columbia |
| 2018 | Red Deer Legends | Alberta |
| 2017c | Oakville Golden A's / Happy Islanders | Ontario / British Columbia |
| 2016 | Happy Islanders | British Columbia |
bTournament cancelled due to COVID-19
cCo-Champions due to rain