| Game | Season | Career | |
|
Points |
Brandon Murphy- 74 |
Brandon Murphy- 422 | Jeff Taylor- 1,681 |
| Rebounds | Joshuah Wilson- 37 | Gerry Hall- 237 | Joshuah Wilson- 731 |
| Assists |
Tyler Clemens- 19 Ricky Thompson-19 |
Tyler Clemens- 99 | Brandon Murphy- 383 |
| Steals | Dez Farrell- 8 | Hunter Boils- 41 | Hunter Boils- 138 |
| Blocks |
Spencer Stewart- 7 Chris Robinson- 7 |
Chris Robinson- 31 | Chris Robinson- 78 |
| 3's Made | Jeff Taylor- 18 | Ricky Thompson- 77 | Jeff Taylor- 297 |
| Regular Season MVP | Finals MVP | |
| Season 1 | Jeff Taylor | Cole McDaniel |
| Season 2 | Dezmond Farrell | Cole McDaniel |
| Season 3 | Brandon Murphy | Chris Robinson |
| Season 4 | Ricky Thompson | Jeff Taylor |
| Season 5 | Jeff Taylor | Dezmond Farrell |
| Season 6 | ||
| Season 7 | ||
| Season 8 | ||
| Season 9 |
| Championship Game | League Champion | |
| Season 1 | New Castle Trojans vs Cadiz Spaniards | Cadiz Spaniards |
| Season 2 | New Lisbon Tigers vs Cadiz Spaniards | Cadiz Spaniards |
| Season 3 | New Castle Trojans vs Sulphur Springs Bluebirds | Sulphur Springs Bluebirds |
| Season 4 | New Lisbon Tigers vs Mount Summit Eagles | New Lisbon Tigers |
| Season 5 | New Castle Trojans vs Kennard Leopardcats | New Castle Trojans |
| Season 6 | ||
| Season 7 | ||
| Season 8 | ||
| Season 9 |
| Teams | Wins | Losses |
| New Lisbon Tigers | 32 | 16 |
| New Castle Trojans | 31 | 17 |
| Cadiz Spaniards | 30 | 18 |
| Mount Summit Eagles | 29 | 19 |
| Mooreland Bobcats | 22 | 26 |
| Lewisville Bears | 14 | 26 |
| Sulphur Springs Bluebirds (Knightstown Falcons) | 13 | 27 |
| Kennard Leopardcats (Spiceland Stingers) | 13 | 35 |